Children who receive a combination of melatonin and behavioral therapy fall asleep faster and have better sleep quality than those who get either treatment alone or those on placebo, according to a study published 22 May in the Journal of Sleep Research1.
Many children with autism have difficulty falling asleep and sleeping through the night, and a study last year showed that children with the disorder spend less time in the rapid eye movement phase of sleep than controls do.
Lack of sleep can aggravate behavioral problems in children with the disorder. Sleep is also crucial for healthy brain development, underscoring the importance of sleep for these children.
A study published 19 May in Psychoneuroendocrinology built on these results by looking at the levels of melatonin in the urine of 46 teenagers with autism and 26 controls in a 24-hour period2.
Melatonin levels are known to be about three times higher at night than during the day. Teenagers with autism have a similar ratio, but have less melatonin in their urine than do controls at all times, the study found. This suggests that it is the production of the hormone, and not the circadian rhythm, that is disrupted in teenagers with the disorder.
In the new study, researchers treated 134 children with autism from 4 to 10 years of age for sleep problems. They divided the children into four groups: behavioral therapy alone, controlled-release melatonin alone, both melatonin and therapy, or placebo.
The therapy involved training parents during four weekly 50-minute sessions to help them manage negative behaviors surrounding sleep. For example, parents were taught how to maintain consistent sleep schedules and avoid late-day naps.
The researchers evaluated the children before and after 12 weeks of treatment, using a sleep monitoring system that uses movement to track how long it took them to fall asleep, how long they slept in total, how many times they woke during the night, and their sleep efficiency, defined as the ratio of sleep to time spent in bed. They also gave parents the Children’s Sleep Habits Questionnaire, and used a parental sleep diary to discard data from unusual nights, such as when the child was sick.
Melatonin or behavioral therapy alone each improves sleep, the study found. However, a combination of the two is the most effective. For example, on average, the children fell asleep about 52 minutes earlier after combined therapy, 36 minutes earlier after melatonin treatment and 17 minutes earlier after therapy alone. In contrast, those who got the placebo took, on average, 78 minutes to fall asleep before treatment and 80 minutes after.
Responses to the questionnaire suggest that melatonin affects the onset of sleep, night waking and sleep duration, whereas cognitive therapy alleviates sleep-related anxiety.
1: Cortesi F. et al. J. Sleep Res. Epub ahead of print (2012) PubMed
2: Tordjman S. et al. Psychoneuroendocrinology Epub ahead of print (2012) PubMed